Even when both male and female college students say they want to pursue a major with the best earnings prospects, the majors men choose are higher paying than the majors women choose.
In a new study, sociologist Natasha Quadlin of The Ohio State University found that "the logics of major choice" may lead women to select different majors from men, despite having similar preferences.
"Even when women place great emphasis on earnings, other preferences may ultimately win out for them," said Quadlin, assistant professor of sociology at Ohio State.
One possible competing preference: finding a field that's a good fit.
The study appears online in the journal Sociology of Education.
Quadlin used data from the Pathways through College Study, which surveyed 2,720 students from three higher education institutions that had programs intended to attract and retain STEM majors.
Each student was asked during their first term to rate on a scale of 1 to 5 how important four considerations were to them when selecting a major: money earned, career options, engaging classes, and helping others.
Students later reported which major they selected. Quadlin also used federal data to examine the earnings associated with each major.
"The pattern was clear: The majors men choose are associated with significantly higher earning than the majors women choose -- regardless of men's and women's major preferences," she said.
So when men and women both prioritize economic returns in their preferences for a major, men still choose majors that pay more.
But even when men and women prioritized other preferences for their major -- such as helping people -- men still chose higher-paying majors, the findings showed.
For example, men who said they wanted a major where they could help people were more likely than women to choose biology, a pre-med major, because they thought doctors helped people. But women who wanted to help people were more likely than men to choose nursing.
"Nursing is a relatively high-paying job, but it generally doesn't pay as much as doctors can earn," Quadlin said.
Why do women choose different majors from men, even when they share the same preferences?
One reason may have to do with what jobs men and women think are realistic for them, said Quadlin.
"There's research that suggests men and women have very different ideas about what types of careers and fields are open and available to them," she said.
"Some STEM careers that pay the most may not be as receptive to women as they are to men, so women adjust what majors they select."
The result is that women who are motivated to make a lot of money choose majors that are relatively high-paying, but also more open and available to women, Quadlin said.
The results of the study suggest that attracting women to STEM may not be as easy as changing their preferences, because changing their preferences may not lead them to actually choose the STEM careers they're encouraged to select.
"You may not be able to attract women to high-paying STEM careers just by telling them it is a way to make a lot of money or a way to help other people," Quadlin said.
"Instead, we may have more to do with changing the culture around STEM so that women feel the field is more open and receptive to them."
The study was supported by the Pathways through College Research Network, funded by the National Science Foundation.
Recommended textbook solutionsHDEV5
6th EditionSpencer A. Rathus
380 solutions
Social Psychology
10th EditionElliot Aronson, Robin M. Akert, Timothy D. Wilson
525 solutions
A Concise Introduction to Logic
13th EditionLori Watson, Patrick J. Hurley
1,967 solutions
Psychology
13th EditionGarland, Hans C. Ohanian
680 solutions
Upgrade to remove ads
Only ₩37,125/year
-
Flashcards
-
Learn
-
Test
-
Match
-
Flashcards
-
Learn
-
Test
-
Match
Terms in this set (10)
Ms. S. and her infant just participated in an attachment study. First, Ms. S. was interviewed to determine how she represented her attachment relationship with her own early caregivers. Second, the researchers assessed the quality of her baby's attachment to Ms. S. They are seeking to identify relationships between a parent's own working model of attachment and the quality of the attachment the infants form with them. This attachment study is part of which research tradition?
The nuclear family tradition
Ms. J. participated in an attachment interview assessing her relationship to her early caregivers. Her transcript revealed lapses in logical thinking, especially when she talked about traumatic memories. She would most likely be categorized as
unresolved
Among the differences between adult-adult attachments and child-adult attachments is (are)
All of the above (degree of symmetry, reliance on "felt security" tolerance for separation)
According to Holland's description of modal personal orientations (or personal styles), Danielle has an "enterprising" style- she is sociable, domineering, energetic, ambitious, talkative, and attention getting. According to Holland's Theory of career development, Danielle's career counselor should
work with Danielle to encourage self-awareness so that she can match her career choice to her existing style
In Super's developmental approach to career satisfaction, he argue that an individual's vocational self evolves over time. what is the career developmental stage that usually characterizes adolescents and young adults?
The exploratory stage
Consider the role of gender in selecting a major in college. Which of the following is true?
Women are more likely to choose fields like biological and physical sciences than they were 30 years ago.
Current research indicates that in the last 50 years, gender differences in career development have
changed in some ways, but remained the same in the sense that women still give greater priority to their role as a caregiver in a family, and men still give greater priority to their role as breadwinner.
Karina, a college student, has a strong mastery orientation. We can expect that Karina therefore holds which of the following theories of intelligence?
Incremental theory
When people's performance is affected by stereotype threat, it means that
they either believe a negative stereotype about themselves or they fear that others will judge them based on the stereotype.
For helpers who assume an attachment perspective in their therapeutic approach to clients, what is expected to be the primary mechanism of change?
Establishing a therapeutic bond that functions as a secure base.
Sets with similar termsHuman Development Chapter 12
16 terms
amendezllu
Chapter 12 Quiz
10 terms
caleia_flannigan
Adulthood and Aging Exam 2 Study Guide
75 terms
Samira_101
Development Final Multiple Choice Questions
107 terms
Kelly_MacKenzie
Sets found in the same folderCOUN 5334 Chapter 2
30 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
COUN 5334 Chapter 8
30 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
PSYC 5320 Chapter 3
10 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
COUN 5334 Chapter 9
30 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
Other sets by this creatorStudy.com Counseling Flash Cards
108 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
Algebra 2 Unit Vocabulary
42 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
PSYC 5345 Chapter 15
25 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
COUN 5368 Chapter 13
25 terms
Kaitlyn_Judge16
Verified questionsPSYCHOLOGY
According to Margaret Mead, how does one’s culture influence adolescent development?
Verified answer
QUESTION
Elena won the lottery last night. Afterword, she told her friends that she knew she was going to win. Her friends think that she is so lucky because she won the lottery last year as well. Explain how hindsight bias and the tendency to perceive patterns in random events apply to Elena's winnings.
Verified answer
QUESTION
Geoff and Todd tried to buy tickets to see their favorite band, but they were unable to do so because the show sold out by the time they filled in the online form. Geoff swipes his laptop onto the floor in anger. The best explanation for why he does this is a. the proximity effect. b. GRIT. c. the frustration-aggression principle. d. social scripting. e. deindividuation.
Verified answer
PSYCHOLOGY
What is the electromagnetic spectrum and why do we see only a portion of it?
Verified answer
Myers' Psychology for AP
2nd EditionDavid G Myers
900 solutions
Myers' Psychology for the AP Course
3rd EditionC. Nathan DeWall, David G Myers
955 solutions
HDEV5
6th EditionSpencer A. Rathus
380 solutions
Cognitive Psychology: Connecting Mind, Research, and Everyday Experience
5th EditionE Bruce Goldstein
211 solutions
Other Quizlet setsNew Material Accounting 284 Final
24 terms
clairecward
Biochemistry final exam (chapter 1-18)
20 terms
DrArdis
Business Fall Final
96 terms
kaitlinkeene1
National Building Code of the Philippines
52 terms
Archiejou-kun
Related questionsQUESTION
True/False: Our beliefs about families, based on on own personal experience, are always accurate.
2 answers
QUESTION
what attracts people to one another, including what the film clip showed about mere exposure of mirror vs. reverse mirror images?
3 answers
QUESTION
when one is in a stage of physiological arousal (from exercising or being in a frightening situation) but attributes these feelings to love or attraction to the person present
4 answers
QUESTION
most harmful emotion above jealousy, bitterness and resentment
2 answers